What the FTO Has Decided
Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) has ruled that service on taxpayers by simply posting the notices on the IRIS portal of the Federal Board of Revenue is not valid or legal. In an elaboration, the FTO declared that any act of placing the notices on IRIS without communication at the moment is not satisfactory when read between Section 218(1)(d) and Rule 74 of the Income Tax Rules, 2002. The order notes and the repositiveness of the silent portal posts compromise the grounds of natural justice and fair play.
Legal Basis: Section 218 and Rule 74
The Ombudsman cited the section of the Income Tax Ordinance and the rule of the Income Tax Ordinance which is 218(1)(d) that valid service had to be achieved through effective communication; that had to be meant to reach the taxpayer. An online system with the assumption of day-to-day log-ins into IRIS is not enough. Instead, FBR should make sure it sends notifications of taxpayers in time through SMS and/or email to inform them of notices, hearings and orders.
The Case: Senior Citizen Selected for Audit
The decision came about due to a complaint brought by a 78-year-old taxpayer who had reported income gains of salary, exempt share income under AOP, pension and gains made on bank deposits. Under Section 214C, the case was picked to be audited in tax years 2014 and 2015 by computer ballot. Actions that were taken thereafter were reported mainly via the IRIS portal and not sufficiently directly to the taxpayer.
Directions to FBR and Remand for Fresh Decision
The FTO instructed the Federal Board of Revenue to reconsider re-examinations of approvals of assessment orders issued by the Commissioner (Appeals-III) Karachi on January 12, 2024, and ordered the case to be remanded to the trial court (before the DCIR) to order a new decision on the merits. The order puts stress on corrective action to bring the procedure in line with the due-process standards.
Immediate Relief and Administrative Action
The Ombudsman directed the Commissioner, Zone- III, RTO- II Karachi to detach the bank accounts of the complainant immediately. FTO also requested the Member Operations/Administration of FBR to begin an investigation into the conduct of the Assessing Officer toward the elderly taxpayer- emphasizing on the duty of care and a sense of proportionality in the execution.
Implications for Taxpayers and FBR
To taxpayers, the ruling makes it clear that legal service should not be based on the passive portal postings. In the case of FBR, it requires effective communication between taxpayers and delivery through verifiable channels (SMS/email), better notice records and audit tracks. Increased responsibility was also noted by the FTO in the process of working with senior citizens, such as explicit guidelines, reasonable deadlines, and the availability of channels of complaints.
Practical Guidance: Protecting Your Rights
- Ensure your mobile number and email in IRIS are up to date to receive alerts.
• If you learn of a notice via portal without prior SMS/email, document the gap and seek rescheduling.
• Keep copies of all messages, emails, and screenshots showing when you first became aware of a notice.
• If accounts are attached without proper service, cite Section 218/Rule 74 and the FTO ruling when seeking relief.
