Sindh High Court Orders Retake of MDCAT

October 29, 2024Zayn0

The Sindh High Court has ordered the commission conducting the Medical and Dental College Admission Test, MDCAT, to be retaken within four weeks of judgment. The court came to this conclusion in response to complaints filed with it under several petitions against the restructured test. The exams form an important criterion of entrance for students into various medical and dental colleges of Pakistan.

Background of the Case

It heard before Sindh High Court which evaluated the petitions concerning the MDCAT. During this session, the court expressed its concerns about the acts of the committee in the running of the examination because previously it had passed the judgment to form such a committee to investigate the complaints the petitioners had brought to them so sought some progress since then.

Findings of the Committee

The report, as chairperson Shireen Narejo presented to the court, had findings. The court observed that “the responsibility for the integrity of the examination rests with PMDC and Dow University.” “If no anomalies are found in the examinations, then of course we will consider all the concerns of the petitioners,” the court held. However, it also pointed out that testing agencies always put undue burdens on universities.

Compromised Examination System

The committee had checked the examination system of Dow University. It was brought to light in the hearing that some students wanted their exam not to be repeated, and it was considered. However, the committee found several defects in the examination process of approximately 40-42 persons who conduct the examination.

Shireen Narejo agreed that the exam system was compromised, though questions and answers of exams are circulated through WhatsApp.

 Investigations Underway

The court discussed the role of FIA, that is conducting forensic analysis of phone of those who are accused of misconduct. FIA got deleted messages and took the physical evidence. It was further asked about the investigation on Jinnah Sindh Medical University, where it said that it is almost completed.

Fairness

He focused special attention on giving every student a fair chance. For him, no matter what the FIA and the government do in the course of investigation, no deserving student must be deprived of getting success.

Issues about Result

One of the committee members responded that flaws in the university system meant that increased chances of the system breach had taken place. The court asked Dow University if it was capable enough to conduct exams and said that it was discovered that exam questions had somehow become different from previous ones.

When the court was told that it was the college professors who prepared the question paper, the court was shocked. Justice Panhwar also questioned the PMDC involvement as he pointed out that some regions, for example, Hyderabad, did not announce results, giving rise to the suspicion of having monetary benefits.

High Examination Fees and Accessibility

They claimed to be worried that exams that charged such hefty fees tended to favor elite students against their will. They turned on why it seemed to help favor elite students and sent word to the PMDC counsel that administering the exams is a provincial responsibility.

In the wake of these irregularities, the Sindh High Court has directed that the MDCAT be retaken within a month. This would make sure that each and every student has a fair chance of getting admission into medical and dental colleges with integrity.

Zayn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Prove your humanity: 0   +   3   =  

Search & have fun

Search anytime for whatever you need, for your business, fun or personal needs. LCCI helps you find it easy and fast.

Search & have fun

Search anytime for whatever you need, for your business, fun, or personal needs. LCCI helps you find it easy and fast.

Explore

Users

LCCI

Copyright © 2025 LCCI  All Rights Reserved.
Developed by TARGET MARKETING (PVT) LIMITED

Copyright © 2025 LCCI  All Rights Reserved.
Developed by TARGET MARKETING (PVT) LIMITED.